Bubble idea for 10 people too much

Whilst I agree with trying to see other people, especially if you live alone, I think this will need to be strictly monitored as it opens the way to a rise in the infection

Why the contribution is important

It is so important to me as I feel my mental health is now suffering due to isolation of living on my own.
I fully support the government but I personally need to see my daughter, grandson and even one friend would make my life so much bearable.
My daughter is not coping being home on her own with my grandson , he stayed at my house sometimes before the lockdown.
If we’re sensible I don’t think this would be a problem.

by Lindakeir60 on May 05, 2020 at 01:39PM

Current Rating

Average rating: 3.7
Based on: 7 votes

Comments

  • Posted by emartinedinburgh May 05, 2020 at 13:49

    I agree that this could be beneficial. Family groups of 10 or less could meet in an open space such as a family garden. Small groups of hobbyists could meet in halls large enough to accommodate them while adhering to the 2m apart route and observing hygiene rules..

  • Posted by Escocia May 05, 2020 at 13:57

    I agree that bubbles of 10 should be suffice.
    To be honest the lockdown has been so poorly administered by certain groups of people, without repercussions, that you cant keep people apart forever. If there had been stricter controls we could have been in a better position. Because it hasnt, then why keep insisting on groups apart?

  • Posted by DRoo May 05, 2020 at 14:00

    I would agree that there also needs to be consideration given to reducing restrictions on travel to see immediate family and loved ones. With full restrictions still on place for the entertainment industry including sports. Then we are not greatly increasing any risks of infection spread. We are however increasing people mental health and wellbeing. Which are just as important for our longterm health and reducing long term burdens on the NHS.

  • Posted by Richs May 05, 2020 at 14:01

    I agree this would be a challenge to manage and likely to cause lots of discussion re interpretation and understanding which ultimately could cause conflict and non compliance I believe.

  • Posted by fionacannie May 05, 2020 at 14:03

    I fully support the proposal for families to meet up , initially outdoors and maintaining social distance ( if possible).
    This would help families to support each other particularly family members who may have mental health issues.
    I agree that there would require to be some sort of monitoring. Perhaps people could register and confirm family members who would be included in individual family bubble?

  • Posted by June May 05, 2020 at 14:21

    Vitally important to the well being of the whole nation to allow people to socialise again. The idea of registering who is in your Bubble suggests a police state! We’re not North Korea - yet - but if everyone keeps thinking the government is making all the right choices on their behalf, then we are heading that way. Give people the right to make sensible decisions.

  • Posted by GeorgestripeyTT May 05, 2020 at 14:21

    I think it would be wonderful to meet up with family outside and do have great sympathy for the poster (Lindakeir60). I live in a flat in the South Side of Glasgow but fear that if 10 people were allowed to meet inside this will lead to parties and potential spreading of door handles, noise etc for those living around the apartments which would be difficult for those who do not have many people they speak to and are isolating - it is stressful enough. Definitely need for sense here, but not sure how it is going to be managed as Police don't care about parties from noise and never attend when a report is made.

  • Posted by Gillian66 May 05, 2020 at 14:46

    Agree with comment re allowing people to make some decisions - because they will do it anyway.

    Family no more/less risky than friends.
    Not everyone has 10 family members in reasonable proximity
    Multi-adult households do not necessarily have all the same contact groups in other households
    You cannot police this in any sensible way
    How do you define family ?

  • Posted by lucyw2488 May 05, 2020 at 14:55

    I agree with Gillian66, I moved in with my mum and brother. That is the only family I have however I regard my friends as my extended family. So how would that work? It should be something that is used however I fear it would be abused.

  • Posted by Rachel_T1502 May 05, 2020 at 18:42

    The system in new Zealand seems to be quite successful - allowing people who live alone contact with one person/ household, or people who normally share caregiving slightly expanding social contact etc ... I can't see an arbitrary number such as 10 people working in practice, perhaps expanding social bubble in the early stages would work better based on certain criteria instead and mental well-being based reasons which could perhaps be implemented a bit sooner as some people are really struggling with their mental health at the moment
Log in or register to add comments and rate ideas