Protect the at risk group

The lockdown shouldn't be lifted until the death rate and infection rates drop further. It seems we may have reached the peak but there are too many new cases and deaths for lockdown to be lifted yet.
We would be unnecessarily risking lives if we lift lockdown too soon. It would send a message that everything can go back to normal when that just isn't true. We could end up with a bigger second wave which would be devastating.

Why the contribution is important

We would be unnecessarily risking lives if we lift lockdown too soon. It would send a message that everything can go back to normal when that just isn't true. We could end up with a bigger second wave which would be devastating.

by Jennyc on May 10, 2020 at 12:08PM

Current Rating

Average rating: 4.6
Based on: 10 votes

Comments

  • Posted by AJClubb May 10, 2020 at 12:59

    The alternative is to test and quarantine everyone who comes into contact with high risk people
  • Posted by HelloScotland May 11, 2020 at 09:35

    in the absence of a cure, we must have a strategy of test, track and treat before at-risk groups will feel more comfortable about venturing out again.

    In the first instance, a reliable, timely testing process which is both widely available and accessible is urgently required. Details of local cases should be communicated anonymously to ensure vigilance is maintained.

    With regards to tracking, location based data is available through mobile devices and there needs to be a mechanism where those who have come into contact with someone who has Covid-19, have travelled internationally, or may have otherwise been in contact with a contaminant are notified through an App. If they fail to adhere to the guidance on isolating then there has to be some form of punitive recourse, otherwise it is inevitable that some people will ignore.

    In terms of treatment, it will be dependant on how effective the tracking/control is, however adequate safety equipment and PPE for the NHS and supporting businesses seems to be in inconsistent supply which is a serious concern. As cases become better understood, treatments may evolve however this will be near impossible amidst an overrun of cases so it is important again that control is maintained.

    The comms from Scottish Government have been excellent. Clear and concise. The challenge will be managing movement as we resume normal activities and so, despite many reservations, i do think this needs to be tracked until there is confidence that cases are understood and death rates have significantly reduced.
  • Posted by LR2020 May 11, 2020 at 10:39

    There needs to be VERY clear guidance for vulnerable people who fall into the higher risk (but not shielding) category. Some people who fall into this category may have MORE than one underlying health condition putting them at even higher risk of getting seriously ill if they catch coronavirus.

    Guidance like this would be helpful: (1) continue to observe 'stricter' social distancing measures even when lockdown measures are eased e.g. avoid public transport and large groups of people etc. (2) wear a mask in 'closed' settings e.g. shops (3) strongly encouraged to work from home unless you absolutely can't (4) no requirement to work where 2m social distancing cannot be maintained, (5) must be provided with suitable PPE where necessary e.g. working in certain professions, (6) encouraged to get the flu-jab at earliest possible opportunity (7) continue to self-isolate away from family/other people who have the coronavirus.

    It is essential there is timely testing, tracking and tracing in the general population before encouraging vulnerable people to return to work or resume other social activities.
  • Posted by PCR May 11, 2020 at 12:37

    A more tailored and detailed analysis of risks and needs of those who are highly vulnerable but not in shielding group would be extremely helpful. Individual risk analysis medically would enable a sensible and appropriate guide for those at risk. Perhaps this could be achieved through a questionnaire which would evaluate health and risk factors which then sets out a more precise and tailored plan or guide reflecting the complexity and diversity of individuals. At the moment, there are many highly vulnerable people who are not in the shielding group, and just as vulnerable to serious impact of covid19.
Log in or register to add comments and rate ideas

Idea topics